Week 1 Is Here: The Starts, The Sits & The Fights They Couldn't Finish
Week 1 opened Wednesday night, but every call in this drop is still ahead of you. First kickoff is noon Central.
Here's your full Week 1 breakdown, position by position. We went through the guys' takes so you don't have to, and we're reporting back on who they'd start, who they'd bench, and where they couldn't agree on either.
One thing before you scroll: this is what the guys said, not what your roster needs. League size, scoring and bench depth change the answer, and none of that is in here.
Read it against your own setup
- Deep leagues: a bench call is still your best option sometimes. If there's nobody behind him, play him.
- Shallow leagues: you've probably got a real alternative sitting right there. Go look before you accept a sit.
- Flex: where the upside lives. The guys put Rico Dowdle and Tre Tucker in that range this week.
- The split calls: section three is a coin flip by design. Both sides are in there, and we're not picking for you — that one's yours.
Bottom line: if you see bench and your lineup already looks thin, don't panic. Play the best you've got, trust the roster you built, and don't tinker just to tinker.
1. Locked In: The Starts Nobody's Arguing About
Quarterback
- Justin Herbert (Chargers): High-confidence start across the board, with some of the room slotting him as high as QB2. Arizona's defense is vulnerable and the thinking is that a clean pocket lets the Chargers basically pick a number.
- Jared Goff (Lions): Top-five start and, for a few of them, the QB1 of the week. Home, in a dome, against a New Orleans defense that gave up multiple passing scores to nine different quarterbacks last season.
- Baker Mayfield (Buccaneers): Strong starter or streamer against Cincinnati in the game carrying the highest over/under on the slate. Fully healthy offensive line and a receiving room that's all active.
- Josh Allen (Bills): Houston's a tough road draw and his numbers there have historically been lower. Doesn't matter — he was the first quarterback off the board and he's a season-long start, full stop.
- Malik Willis (Dolphins): Confident high-upside streamer against Las Vegas, a defense that gave up the fourth-most rushing yards to designed quarterback runs last year. This one's a rushing-floor play.
- Trevor Lawrence (Jaguars): Solid QB1 at home against a Cleveland defense breaking in a new coordinator and playing without Myles Garrett, who got traded out of the division this offseason.
- Dak Prescott (Cowboys): Consensus top-seven start against the Giants. No qualifiers attached.
- Tyler Shough (Saints): A situational start when the dome environment is right, and a few of the guys would take him over Jayden Daniels this week. Detroit's secondary is banged up and the game total is high.
Running Back
- Jahmyr Gibbs (Lions) and Bijan Robinson (Falcons): The overall RB1 and RB2. Locked in, nothing to discuss.
- Derrick Henry (Ravens): Locked-in RB1 against Indianapolis.
- Omarion Hampton (Chargers): Top-10 back against Arizona's weak run defense, with the game script pointing his way all afternoon.
- Ashton Jeanty (Raiders): Back-end RB1 or high RB2 against Miami, projected to take roughly 80% of the backfield touches.
- Bucky Irving (Buccaneers): Strong RB2 against Cincinnati, and the upside ticked up with Sean Tucker dealing with an undisclosed injury. That's the goal-line work opening up.
- Breece Hall (Jets): Must-start RB1 on the road at Tennessee, who finished 28th in fantasy points allowed to backs last season. Projection is 18 to 20 touches.
- Rico Dowdle (Steelers): Flex or RB2 against Atlanta's depleted defense, with goal-line preference and heavy touch volume expected. Worth reading the Steelers backfield debate below before you lock it — not everyone agrees the split is that clean.
- Chuba Hubbard (Panthers): Confirmed the starter in Carolina against a Chicago run defense that isn't good. Jonathon Brooks is working back slowly, so the early-season volume is his.
Wide Receiver
- Chris Olave (Saints): Top-five spot, graded WR8, at Ford Field against Detroit. One of the cleanest matchups on the board.
- Parker Washington (Jaguars): Unanimous start and a top-20 slot receiver this week. Cleveland is weak inside, and with Denzel Ward shadowing Brian Thomas Jr., the target share funnels to Washington.
- Luther Burden III (Bears): Start him, with top-10 upside against Carolina. Rome Odunze is nursing an injury, and Burden's designed touches come away from Jaycee Horn.
- Chris Godwin Jr. (Buccaneers): WR2/WR3 in a projected shootout with Cincinnati. Zac Robinson's offense is using heavy pre-snap motion, and Godwin is the beneficiary.
- Quentin Johnston (Chargers): High-upside WR2/WR3 against an Arizona secondary that can't hold up.
- Tetairoa McMillan (Panthers): WR17 with upside against Chicago's pass defense.
- Jayden Reed and Christian Watson (Packers): Both recommended starts against Minnesota's secondary.
- Jameson Williams (Lions): Top-20 receiver in what should be a fast game against New Orleans.
- Tre Tucker (Raiders): Flex or better now that Brock Bowers is out. The guys put his target share at 24–25% in the games Bowers missed.
Tight End
- Michael Mayer (Raiders): The consensus must-start and the top waiver replacement after Brock Bowers' meniscus surgery. Without Bowers last season he ran a 24% target share and averaged double-digit PPR points, and Miami gave up top-three fantasy production to tight ends. The room took him over Travis Kelce and Dalton Kincaid.
- Juwan Johnson (Saints): Top-10 tight end in an indoor shootout at Detroit. With Jordyn Tyson out, he's functioning as the Saints' second option.
- Mark Andrews (Ravens): Start and a sleeper call against Indianapolis, with high-end TE1 upside.
- Isaiah Likely (Giants): Start and sleeper call against Dallas.
- Dallas Goedert (Eagles): Trusted start as the target Jalen Hurts goes back to when he needs one. Washington's the matchup.
Defense / Special Teams
- Jaguars D/ST: Unanimous number one defense of the week against Deshaun Watson and a Cleveland offense that isn't scaring anybody.
- Steelers D/ST: High upside against Atlanta, who's turning to Cooper Rush — and he's dealing with back spasms — behind shaky pass protection. Pittsburgh rotates T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith and Nick Herbig off the edge.
- Eagles D/ST: Recommended start against Washington.
- Cowboys D/ST: Recommended start against the Giants.
2. Leave Them On The Bench
Quarterback
- Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs): Unanimous sit, which is a sentence nobody expected to type. He's nine months out from ACL/LCL surgery, facing a Denver pass rush, working behind undrafted rookie left tackle Kahlil Benson, with low projected passing volume.
- Deshaun Watson (Browns): Explicit bench on the road at Jacksonville, who defend the run and the pass.
- Bo Nix (Broncos): Sit in one-quarterback formats against Kansas City.
- Kirk Cousins (Raiders): Sit in one-quarterback leagues.
Running Back
- Quinshon Judkins (Browns): Explicit bench. Cleveland is a 10-point road underdog against a stout Jacksonville run defense.
- Jonathon Brooks (Panthers): Bench. Lingering injury and soreness, and Chuba Hubbard has the starter's job.
- Jeremiyah Love (Cardinals): Bench. Coming off a high ankle sprain, second on the depth chart, and drawing a tough Chargers front.
- J.K. Dobbins (Broncos): Sit or avoid against Kansas City's front.
- Aaron Jones (Vikings): Fade, based on how late 2025 went and on Jordan Mason taking the job.
- Mike Washington Jr. (Raiders): Bench stash only, parked behind Ashton Jeanty.
Wide Receiver
- Carnell Tate (Titans): Unanimous sit against the Jets defense.
- Stefon Diggs (Commanders): Sit against Philadelphia. Limited slot role and Cooper DeJean waiting for him there.
- Michael Pittman Jr. (Steelers): The bench call came attached to a Baltimore matchup — but that was his Colts schedule. He's in Pittsburgh now and Pittsburgh plays Atlanta, so the reasoning behind the sit doesn't line up with his actual game.
Tight End
- Brock Bowers (Raiders): Out for Week 1 after a meniscus trim, with an expected absence of one to two games or more.
- Travis Kelce (Chiefs): Explicit bench in a game projected to stay low-scoring against Denver, with Michael Mayer named as the play over him.
- Dalton Kincaid (Bills): Benched against a Houston defense that ranks top-10 against tight ends, in another low-scoring projection.
- Jake Ferguson (Cowboys): Sit and wait-and-see against the Giants.
Defense / Special Teams
- Bears D/ST: Explicit sit, and more than that — the guys are treating Chicago's defense as something to target, not something to roster.
3. Where The Room Splits
Quarterback
- Jayden Daniels (Commanders): Real disagreement. The rushing floor keeps him inside the top 12 for some of them; others bench him against Philadelphia because of an offensive line they described as unusable during joint practices.
- Jaxson Dart (Giants): Top 10 for the rushing upside, QB22 or QB23 for the guys who think a revamped Dallas defense takes the scrambling away.
- Jordan Love (Packers): Split. Strong touchdown efficiency against Minnesota's blitz-heavy look, but the Green Bay offensive line widens the range of outcomes considerably.
- Kyler Murray (Vikings): Flagged as a rushing sleeper against a Green Bay defense missing Micah Parsons, and questioned by others over low passing volume.
Running Back
- MarShawn Lloyd (Packers): The biggest fight in the notes. One side has him as a locked-in RB2 with 15-plus touches; the other has him at RB28 or RB42 on Green Bay's line questions and Minnesota's interior run defense.
- Jordan Mason (Vikings): The direct counterweight to Lloyd. Some of the guys have him as the clear lead back, others bench him in PPR.
- Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle (Steelers): A murky committee against Atlanta. Warren gets the nod in PPR, Dowdle in standard and half-PPR.
Wide Receiver
- Emeka Egbuka (Buccaneers): Severe disagreement. Half the room calls him a start; the other half sits him over lingering turf toe and a matchup with DJ Turner II.
- Malik Nabers (Giants): Vague coaching quotes about his snap count split the room — down to WR25 for some, in the lineup for others.
- Rome Odunze (Bears): Game-time decision with a calf and foot issue. If he plays, he's a PPR start. If he doesn't, Luther Burden III's value jumps.
- DJ Moore (Bills): Knocked down to WR3 or flex because of Houston's defense, but the guys keep him in PPR lineups for the screen volume.
- Dontayvion Wicks (Eagles): An analytics favorite and a popular waiver stash, but some rankers want to see the target share before they start him.
Tight End
- Tucker Kraft (Packers): The touchdown equity is there, the snap count is the problem — around 60% coming off injury.
- Greg Dulcich (Dolphins): A sleeper dart throw, with no proven weekly floor to lean on.
Defense / Special Teams
- Raiders D/ST over Bears D/ST: A slight lean toward Las Vegas, but the guys treat both as low-end streamers. If you have a better option, use it.
Sunday's first wave kicks at noon Central and every call in here is still live. Go move somebody.
→ Follow @girlswhodraftGo get your guy.