Drop One: Vocabulary, Consensus & the Fights Before Draft Night
Welcome back. Or welcome, period, if this is your first year.
Here's the deal with this newsletter: we sift through hours of guys arguing about fantasy football every week so you don't have to, and hand you the part that matters.
This is the first drop of the year, so it's the big one. Vocabulary, then the consensus, then the fights. Save it. You'll want it on draft night.
Part 1: The words everyone uses and nobody defines
ADP — Average Draft Position. The average spot a player gets picked across thousands of drafts. It's not a ranking, it's a price. Track it in the days before your draft and you'll see who's climbing and who's sliding, which tells you who you can wait on and who you have to reach for.
PPR — Points Per Reception. A full point every time your guy catches the ball. If your league is PPR, catch volume matters as much as yardage, which is why slot receivers and pass-catching backs go earlier than your gut says they should.
Target share and A.D.O.T. Target share is the percentage of a team's throws going to one player. A.D.O.T. — average depth of target — is how far downfield he is when the ball comes. Low A.D.O.T. slot guys catch short, easy passes every week: high floor, boring, reliable. High A.D.O.T. deep threats win you a week with one play and vanish for the next three. You want both. You just have to know which one you're drafting.
Zero RB vs. Hero RB. Zero RB means skipping running backs entirely through the first five or six rounds, stacking elite receivers and a tight end, then loading your bench with backs who are one injury from a starting job. Hero RB means taking one workhorse early, then ignoring the position for several rounds while you dominate everywhere else. Both work. Picking one before you sit down is the part people skip.
Tier-based drafting. Stop reading rankings as a numbered list. Group players into tiers of similar value instead. The moment a tier is about to empty out, that's your signal to grab from it — or pivot to a position where the talent hasn't dried up yet. This one habit will save you more picks than any sleeper list.
Part 2: What they actually agree on
Fantasy content is built on disagreement, but a few things are settled.
The running back cliff is real and it's early. The top of the position is a small group of true workhorses, and Kenneth Walker III — now in Kansas City after signing there in free agency, coming off a Super Bowl MVP — sits right at the edge of it, somewhere in the RB11 to RB13 range. Past that line, reliable volume falls off a cliff. Get one of those backs early. This is the least controversial opinion in fantasy football.
Your bench is for handcuffs, not mediocre starters. The classic beginner move is filling six bench spots with fine-ish RB3s you'll never start. Don't. Fill them with backups who inherit a full workload the second the starter goes down. Names going in the double-digit rounds: Mike Washington Jr. (Raiders, behind Ashton Jeanty), Blake Corum (Rams, behind Kyren Williams), Emmett Johnson (Chiefs rookie out of Nebraska, now behind Walker), and Jonah Coleman (Broncos rookie getting all-rookie buzz).
Wait on your quarterback — but not as long as you've been told. The math is the whole argument. Last year's QB1 in points per game averaged 22.0. QB12 averaged 18.0. That's a four-point gap. At running back, RB12 averaged 14.1 and RB37 averaged 8.0 — a 6.1-point gap. Positional scarcity lives at running back, not quarterback.
So: Josh Allen goes around pick 28, Lamar Jackson around 49, and if you skip both you can have Justin Herbert or Trevor Lawrence in the low 80s or Bo Nix around 108. One flag, because this one is being repeated everywhere and it's wrong — Caleb Williams is not a late-round QB this year. He's going around pick 71. If you want him, you're spending a sixth-rounder.
Tight end: pay up or punt. The position is brutally top-heavy. Brock Bowers (ADP ~20) and Trey McBride (~24) cost you a second-round pick and buy you a weekly advantage nobody else in your league has. If you're not paying that, don't nibble in the middle — wait it out and take Isaiah Likely (now on the Giants catching passes from Jaxson Dart, ADP ~115) or Juwan Johnson in New Orleans (~121). The middle of this position is where draft capital goes to die.
Fade age and fade fresh surgical scars. The historical record on drafting 33-and-older receivers inside the first nine rounds is not good, which puts Mike Evans — now a 49er at 33 years old, going around pick 61 — squarely in the danger zone. Davante Adams in Los Angeles is going late in the fourth round, though the case against him is touchdown regression more than age: he scored 14 last year on his lowest receptions-per-game since 2015. And Quinshon Judkins is working back from a fractured fibula and dislocated ankle that ended his season and required surgery. Let someone else find out.
Part 3: The five fights
Christian McCaffrey — anchor or landmine? He's 30. His yards per carry dropped to 3.9 last season, well under his 4.6 career mark. He went eight of his last ten games without a single touch longer than 20 yards. San Francisco has spent top-150 picks on running backs three years running, which is a front office hedging. And he's dealing with hamstring tightness in camp right now. The other side of it: nobody else at the position has his ceiling, and a healthy McCaffrey wins leagues. He's going in the middle of round one. That's the price of the argument.
Luther Burden III vs. Rome Odunze. The Bears offense projects to score a lot, so somebody here is going to be worth owning. Burden goes around pick 43 as WR23 and is working back from a groin injury. Odunze — and to be clear, he is not a rookie, he was the ninth overall pick in 2024 — goes roughly 15 picks later at WR28. Cheaper, bigger, better in the red zone. The fade case on Burden is that the efficiency hype is running ahead of the actual fantasy points. The Odunze case is that you get most of the offense for two rounds less.
Jameson Williams. You're going to hear this called a "third-year breakout." It isn't. He's entering year five and the breakout already happened — he finished as the overall WR10 last season with back-to-back 1,000-yard years, and from Week 9 on, after Dan Campbell took play-calling away from John Morton, he was the fantasy WR5. He's going around pick 49 as WR24, which is a discount on a guy who just finished WR10. The bear case is his floor: he's had multiple zero-catch games. Worth noting that Sam LaPorta is working back from a serious back injury, which thins out the target competition further.
Rashee Rice. This is the one where the market genuinely can't agree — he's going anywhere from 15th overall to the third round, which should tell you how split the room is. The concerns: Eric Bieniemy has replaced Matt Nagy as Chiefs OC and the scheme may not suit Rice's short-area game, and he served a 30-day jail sentence in Texas for a probation violation plus had knee surgery this offseason. The counter: he averaged 18.8 PPR points per game in 2025, and he's been looking like himself in camp. Whatever you decide, he is not a bargain. Anyone calling him the steal of the draft is quoting last year's price.
Kyle Pitts. ADP around 77, TE7. Kevin Stefanski is the new head coach in Atlanta with Tommy Rees calling plays, and the fade argument rests on the quarterback — except here's the part everyone keeps skipping: Tua Tagovailoa has not been named the starter. As of this week it's still an open competition with Michael Penix Jr. If you're drafting Pitts, you're drafting into an unresolved quarterback room. Price that in.
Part 4: Three things to actually do on draft night
Buy the easy September. Some players open the year against defenses that can't stop them. Omarion Hampton and the Chargers draw the Cardinals, Raiders and Bills early — three of the softer run defenses in the league last season. Kyler Murray, now starting in Minnesota, has one of the friendlier opening stretches at quarterback. Draft the hot start, then trade it in October to the manager panicking about his slow-starting stud. Never get married to your draft-day roster.
Grab the boring slot guys. If you go running back heavy early, stabilize your PPR lineup later with high-volume short-area receivers. KC Concepcion went 24th overall to Cleveland and profiles exactly like this. Wan'Dale Robinson is in Tennessee now and is going to catch a lot of passes on a team without many other options. Neither will win you a week. Both will stop you from losing one.
Scout your league, not just the players. If your league-mates panic-draft quarterbacks and tight ends early every year, the late-round strategy that works everywhere else will leave you with scraps. Know your room.
That's drop one. More coming as ADP moves between now and draft night. In the meantime, the daily stuff lives on Instagram.
→ Follow @girlswhodraftGo get your guy.